Industry Insights

How Retirements Undermine Manufacturing Productivity and What to Do About It


Manufacturing companies are entering a period where retirements threaten not just workforce size but overall productivity. McKinsey warns that “seasoned workers are retiring at rapid rates, leaving manufacturers with a shortage of experts who can bring new-joiners up to speed.” This creates a situation in which experience and tacit knowledge vanish, while new employees require longer learning curves to reach proficiency. 

For leaders in cost engineering and product development, this challenge requires urgent attention. Knowledge retention has become essential for protecting productivity and safeguarding processes as demographic shifts accelerate. 

An Aging Workforce Is Reshaping Manufacturing 

Across manufacturing, the proportion of employees over the age of 55 has steadily increased since the 1990s. In the United States, the share of older manufacturing employees has almost doubled in thirty years. 

Line chart showing the rising share of US manufacturing employees over 55 years old from 1995 to 2025.

With nearly 15 million people working in U.S. manufacturing, the aging workforce will continue to influence performance. When experienced employees retire, they take decades of expertise in processes, cost structures, and supplier management with them, thereby leaving significant gaps in operations. 

Retirement Rates Are Rising Faster Than Expected 

The pandemic accelerated an already pressing issue. McKinsey notes that retirement rates in manufacturing “spiked during the COVID-19 pandemic and have remained elevated since.” Companies are now dealing with faster workforce exits, which in turn makes continuity harder to maintain. 

Line chart showing retirement rates among US manufacturing employees from 2014 to 2024, with a spike during the COVID-19 period.

The data confirms that retirements are not only a demographic trend that unfolds over decades but also a short-term disruption with immediate consequences for productivity. 

Why Retirements Hurt Productivity 

Every retirement means the loss of embedded expertise that cannot be replaced overnight. New employees must climb a steep learning curve before they can handle processes independently, which extends training timelines and lowers productivity in the meantime. 

The productivity impact becomes more severe in highly complex roles. McKinsey’s research demonstrates that “the productivity gap between high- and low-performing employees grows significantly as job complexity increases.”

Bar chart showing that the productivity gap between high- and lower-skilled workers widens significantly with job complexity, peaking at 800% for very high complexity jobs.

In jobs with very high complexity, productivity differences can reach up to 800 percent. Losing just one highly skilled worker in cost engineering, tooling, or supplier negotiations can therefore have disproportionate effects on organizational performance. 

The Risk of Losing Key Knowledge 

The expertise at risk extends beyond documented procedures. It is tacit knowledge: the intuition that guides troubleshooting, the understanding of how technical design changes influence costs, and the familiarity with supplier dynamics that improves negotiations. When this knowledge disappears, companies face: 

  • Higher error rates and rework 

  • Longer development cycles 

  • Inconsistent costing approaches 

  • Reduced competitiveness in sourcing and pricing 

These risks highlight why knowledge retention must be treated as a business priority with measurable outcomes. 

Four Strategies to Protect Knowledge Before Employees Retire 

Manufacturers can take several measures to reduce the impact of retirements and preserve institutional knowledge: 

  1. Codify tacit knowledge by documenting critical processes, creating structured digital SOPs, and recording calculation methods. 

  2. Facilitate mentorship programs that pair experienced staff with newer employees for hands-on transfer of expertise. 

  3. Implement digital systems that centralize data, models, and assumptions so they remain available after employee turnover. 

  4. Monitor time to proficiency as a KPI and adjust training programs to accelerate new-hire readiness. 

Such actions ensure that organizations retain continuity and reduce the productivity drag associated with workforce transitions. 

Safeguarding Cost Engineering Expertise Against Retirements 

In cost engineering, retirements place particularly high pressure on organizations. Experienced engineers hold essential knowledge of cost breakdowns, supplier benchmarks, and links between design choices and profitability. Many organizations still manage this information in spreadsheets, which makes it fragmented and difficult to preserve. When employees leave, their models and assumptions often leave with them, thereby weakening cost transparency and decision-making accuracy. 

Tset enables manufacturers to address these challenges by embedding expertise directly into a centralized platform. Cost models, supplier data, and calculation logic become structured and reusable, which ensures that expertise remains part of the organization even as employees retire. By doing so, companies reduce time to proficiency for new hires, maintain consistent costing approaches, and safeguard productivity. 

Conclusion 

The wave of retirements in manufacturing is already reshaping the workforce and will continue to do so in the coming years. McKinsey’s research shows that productivity losses are amplified in complex roles and that organizations must act quickly to preserve expertise. Companies that capture and systematize knowledge will sustain performance, while those that delay will face mounting inefficiencies. 

Tset helps manufacturers retain knowledge and protect productivity. By turning expertise into structured, accessible data, Tset ensures continuity in cost engineering and product development processes. 

Secure Your Expertise Before It Walks Out the Door

Secure your expertise before it walks out the door. Request a Tset demo today and see how our software preserves knowledge and protects productivity.

Book a demo

 

1. Why are retirements such a risk for manufacturing productivity?

Retirements create a knowledge gap that goes beyond workforce numbers. When experienced employees leave, they take tacit knowledge with them — the practical expertise that keeps processes efficient, cost calculations accurate, and supplier negotiations strong. Replacing headcount is possible, but replacing decades of know-how is much harder.

2. What is “time to proficiency” and why does it matter?

Time to proficiency is the period it takes for a new hire to become fully effective in their role. In manufacturing and cost engineering, this timeline grows longer as experienced employees retire. Extended ramp-up times reduce productivity, increase training costs, and weaken process consistency.

3. What kind of knowledge is most at risk when employees retire?

The most vulnerable knowledge is tacit knowledge — insights gained through experience rather than written documentation. This includes troubleshooting methods, supplier benchmarks, cost breakdown logic, and an understanding of how design changes influence profitability. Losing this knowledge disrupts workflows and increases error rates.

4. How can manufacturers retain knowledge from retiring employees?

Practical strategies include:

  • Documenting processes and calculation methods in structured digital formats

  • Creating mentorship and job-shadowing programs

  • Using centralized software to store cost models, supplier data, and assumptions

  • Tracking time to proficiency as a key performance indicator

5. How can software help protect expertise?

Software for product cost calculation ensures that expertise is embedded in a centralized, structured system. Instead of being trapped in spreadsheets or personal files, knowledge becomes reusable, transparent, and accessible to new engineers. This reduces time to proficiency and safeguards productivity as employees retire.

 

Continue reading

Get notified — new blog articles, straight to your inbox.

Get monthly updates on engineering, sustainable manufacturing, and smarter product decisions.

Blog updates